Career records
Points
| PLAYER | YEARS | POINTS |
| Ayden Parsons | 18-22 | 1,021 |
| Ian Schupp | 17-21 | 977 |
| Chad Sprecher | 93-96 | 926 |
| Zach Wilson | 15-19 | 792 |
| Austin Dahn | 03-06 | 744 |
3-point field goals made
| PLAYER | YEARS | 3FG |
| Kyle Lindquist | 04-08 | 113 |
| Jake Hirschy | 16-18 | 110 |
| Ayden Parsons | 18-22 | 92 |
| Chris Kovanda | 02-04 | 92 |
| Jon Mann | 97-00 | 88 |
Field goals made
| PLAYER | YEARS | FG |
| Ian Schupp | 17-21 | 380 |
| Chad Sprecher | 93-96 | 340 |
| Ayden Parsons | 18-22 | 312 |
| Austin Dahn | 03-06 | 264 |
Free throws made
| PLAYER | YEARS | FT |
| Zach Wilson | 15-19 | 251 |
| Chad Sprecher | 93-96 | 203 |
| Aydan Parsons | 18-22 | 312 |
| Ian Schupp | 17-21 | 176 |
| Austin Dahn | 03-06 | 160 |
Total rebounds
| PLAYER | YEARS | REBOUNDS |
| Ian Schupp | 17-21 | 543 |
| Goran Lokas | 05-08 | 484 |
| Joe Chianese | 96-00 | 443 |
| Mike Chambers | 12-14 | 342 |
| Chris Wolever | 99-02 | 316 |
Offensive rebounds
| PLAYER | YEARS | OR |
| Joe Chianese | 96-00 | 163 |
| Goran Lokas | 05-08 | 149 |
| Ian Schupp | 17-21 | 138 |
| Chris Wolever | 99-02 | 128 |
| Mike Chambers | 12-14 | 115 |
Defensive rebounds
| PLAYER | YEARS | DR |
| Ian Schupp | 17-21 | 405 |
| Goran Lokas | 05-08 | 335 |
| Joe Chianese | 96-00 | 280 |
| Mike Chambers | 12-14 | 227 |
| Chris Wolever | 99-02 | 188 |
Blocked shots
| PLAYER | YEARS | BLOCKS |
| Duby Chukwumah | 02-04 | 164 |
| Carson Van Lynn | 13-17 | 162 |
| Goran Lokas | 05-08 | 81 |
| Ben Gaskill | 03-06 | 50 |
Assists
| PLAYER | YEARS | ASSISTS |
| Cayden Dougherty | 17-20 | 404 |
| Gabe Watson | 14-17 | 270 |
| Brian Hanks | 09-12 | 263 |
| Seth Hill | 11-14 | 210 |
| Dan Brooks | 93-96 | 210 |
Field goal percentage
| PLAYER | YEARS | FG% |
| Ben Gaskill | 03-06 | 66.7% |
| Duby Chukwumah | 02-04 | 60.6% |
| Brian Yeo | 91-92 | 60% |
| Goran Lokas | 05-08 | 59.3% |
| Andy Barton | 01-03 | 57.1% |
3-point field goal percentage
| PLAYER | YEARS | 3FG% |
| Rob Korn | 91-92 | 41% |
| Kyle Lindquist | 04-08 | 39.3% |
| Nick Hirschy | 18-22 | 38.6% |
| Jake Hirschy | 16-18 | 34.6% |
| Ayden Parsons | 18-22 | 34.3% |
Free throw percentage
| PLAYER | YEARS | FT% |
| Casey Neal | 94-97 | 81% | Ayden Parsons | 18-22 | 80.7% |
| Austin Dahn | 03-06 | 78.4% |
| Kyle Lindquist | 04-08 | 74.6% |
| Zach Wilson | 15-19 | 73.8% |